Spartan is a silver?

Démarré par Proteus, 21 Février 2011 à 09:43:30

« précédent - suivant »

0 Membres et 0 Invités sur ce sujet

Do you think he belong to Silver Saint class?

silver
15 (33.3%)
he's not
20 (44.4%)
Who damn is Spartan?
10 (22.2%)

Total des votants: 2

Proteus


Spartan, what a particular character! With his gold cosmo (wtf?); his psychokinetic powers said to be one of the greatest in Sanctuary (of course, Mu doesn't live there!); he's the only villain of first season actually not defeated by our heroes. eh eh
His leggend won't stop, since we have no idea what's happened to him after ep 28!!! LOL

Another thing makes fan discuss, wether he can be considered a silver saint, or no.
Let me express the facts, it may be of some interest for Seiyapedia. :)

PRELIMINARY
Spartan appears during Phaeton's office, in which many silver were sent to assassin bronze saint. Actually he attends Shaina and Algol in mission, and he doesn't cut a poor figure. He embarrass Shiryu, who will defeat Perseus saint.
So it'd make sense for him to belong to this class. And it shouldn't be too unlikely , because we already have the example of filler saint who 're declared silver: Tarantual, Pavo & Lotum. Eventually not regular, but their clothes are made of silver. ;)

CON
Unlike Arachne, Spartan doesn't state his class in the TV show.
Agora and Shiva neither; but we know they're silver from JGS2 databook.
What does it say about Spartan? Nothing in his description; but in the  Data Bank he's just a Sonota (other)
So at that time it doesn't look they wanted him to be a silver. :(

PRO
Spartan even makes an appearance in a SS videogame, SaintParadise for GB. :D
When he introduces himself:

SUPARUTAN: Siruba Seinto no Shin no Chikara Miseteyaru.
Spartan: I'll show you Silver Saint's true power.

And you've to know he's the only the only character who says such a thing in the game, along with Marin at the beginning of the chapt.
It' can't be just a coincidence! It makes me think they wanted to establish him as a silver saint, than the previous.

CON
But in the SD carda, at the same period, Spartan isn't stated as a silver (although I can't see well what's written)
Spoiler
So it doesn't seem they really change their position about.

PRO
Let's jump to 2000s. Episode were released in DVD with very nice booklet full of settei. Spartan's one is in Dragon Box.
And what it's more important he's placed between the silver saint.
If they didn't want to suggest that, they'd have put him the page before, as they did for Reda and Spica.
Spoiler


silver saint start now:

Or place him at the end, with the name in a different colour, to separate graphically; as they did for Saint A B C

CONCLUSION
So this is the last retcon?
The possibilities of having a myth cloth of Spartan are rather far LOL.

What we have to think about such guy? Let me know and vote the poll! ;)

Wild Pegasus

I voted yes because indeed at this stage of the anime we're in the Silver Saint arc so any enemy appearing at this moment must belong to that class. However, it's only a Silver Saint in the Anime universe / reality and whose constellation remains unknown.

Benji

He's a silver indeed. [:aloy]
Why? Because the staff of the anime made him in this way! [:lol]
教えて流星たちよ、どれくらいこの場所で待てばいいの?

Saint Alphazero

In my point of view, he is a Wood Saint.
Be sure of my informations.  [:aie]

DeathMask28

"Men judge generally more by the eye than by the hand, for everyone can see and few can feel. Every one sees what you appear to be, few really know what you are." Machiavel

Kodeni

Non pour moi également. Rien ne permet d'affirmer qu'il est un Silver Saint. Pour moi, il est un mercenaire à la Docrates (pas le même niveau cela dit).
Pourquoi ne sommes nous pas immortels ? La menace qui plane sur le monde l'est bien elle !

saucisse

Non, ce n'est pas un Silver. Je cite pour me justifier le même livret DVD: son settei apparaît bien avec les autres Silver mais à la fin du même livret il est listé comme "autres saints" (c'est le même problème avec Guilty toujours associé aux Black Saints). Il me semble qu'il est aussi listé comme "autre" dans les Jump Gold.
Dans Saint Seiya il y a un alpha et un...non, rien d'autre en fait.

Proteus

What page do you mean? May I miss something?

In the page I've posted Guilty is clearly separated through a line from the Black Saint (Jango+black three)


Jump Selection were published twenty years ago, while this material is much more recent...

Archange

Citation de: Proteus le 13 Avril 2011 à 13:06:01
What page do you mean? May I miss something?


The final table in the DVD BOX 2'booklet clearly separates Spartan from the Silver Saints

http://www.saintseiyapedia.com/wiki/Fichier:Spartan_08.jpg

So, his presence on the "Silver" chapter earlier was only because of page layout purpose I guess.